8
Are We in an AI Bubble? Here’s What 13 Economists Told Us
You’re our first priority.
Every time.
NerdWallet, Inc. is an independent publisher and comparison service, not an investment advisor. Its articles, interactive tools and other content are provided to you for free, as self-help tools and for informational purposes only. They are not intended to provide investment advice. NerdWallet does not and cannot guarantee the accuracy or applicability of any information in regard to your individual circumstances. Examples are hypothetical, and we encourage you to seek personalized advice from qualified professionals regarding specific investment issues. Our estimates are based on past market performance, and past performance is not a guarantee of future performance.
We believe everyone should be able to make financial decisions with confidence. And while our site doesn’t feature every company or financial product available on the market, we’re proud that the guidance we offer, the information we provide and the tools we create are objective, independent, straightforward — and free.
So how do we make money? Our partners compensate us. This may influence which products we review and write about (and where those products appear on the site), but it in no way affects our recommendations or advice, which are grounded in thousands of hours of research. Our partners cannot pay us to guarantee favorable reviews of their products or services. Here is a list of our partners.
Are We in an AI Bubble? Here’s What 13 Economists Told Us
We asked more than a dozen economists if we're in an AI bubble and got some pretty clear results.
Many, or all, of the products featured on this page are from our advertising partners who compensate us when you take certain actions on our website or click to take an action on their website. However, this does not influence our evaluations. Our opinions are our own. Here is a list of our partners and here's how we make money.
The investing information provided on this page is for educational purposes only. NerdWallet, Inc. does not offer advisory or brokerage services, nor does it recommend or advise investors to buy or sell particular stocks, securities or other investments.
Published · 3 min readHow is this page expert verified?
NerdWallet's content is fact-checked for accuracy, timeliness and relevance. It undergoes a thorough review process involving writers and editors to ensure the information is as clear and complete as possible.
More on our editorial rigor
Lead Writer
9 years of experience Expertise Stocks ETFs economic newsSam Taube writes about investing for NerdWallet. He has covered investing and financial news since earning his economics degree from the University of Maryland in 2016. Sam has previously written for Investopedia, Benzinga, Seeking Alpha, Wealth Daily and Investment U, and has worked as an editor for Investment U, Wealth Daily and Haven Investment Letter. He is based in Brooklyn, New York.
Sam Taube writes about investing for NerdWallet. He has covered investing and financial news since earning his economics degree from the University of Maryland in 2016. Sam has previously written for Investopedia, Benzinga, Seeking Alpha, Wealth Daily and Investment U, and has worked as an editor for Investment U, Wealth Daily and Haven Investment Letter. He is based in Brooklyn, New York. Published in Lead Writer + more + more
Managing Editor
12 years of experience Expertise Brokerage accounts stock market cryptocurrencyChris Davis is a Managing Editor on the Investing team. He has passed the Series 65 (Uniform Investment Adviser Law Exam) and covered the stock market, investing strategies, investment accounts and cryptocurrency. His work has appeared in The Associated Press, The Washington Post, MSN, Yahoo Finance, MarketWatch, Newsday and TheStreet.
Chris Davis is a Managing Editor on the Investing team. He has passed the Series 65 (Uniform Investment Adviser Law Exam) and covered the stock market, investing strategies, investment accounts and cryptocurrency. His work has appeared in The Associated Press, The Washington Post, MSN, Yahoo Finance, MarketWatch, Newsday and TheStreet. Published in Managing Editor + more + moreThere’s no bulletproof way to identify an investment bubble before it happens, or even while it’s happening. We can only pinpoint bubbles in hindsight, after they’ve already burst — and lost a lot of investors a lot of money.
There’s no bulletproof way to identify an investment bubble before it happens, or even while it’s happening. We can only pinpoint bubbles in hindsight, after they’ve already burst — and lost a lot of investors a lot of money.But when people look back on bubbles of the past, like the dot-com bubble of the late 1990s or the housing bubble of the mid 2000s, many recall a vague feeling that something was off.
But when people look back on bubbles of the past, like the dot-com bubble of the late 1990s or the housing bubble of the mid 2000s, many recall a vague feeling that something was off something was off .It’s no secret that many experts have that feeling right now about the current AI boom. Even OpenAI CEO Sam Altman, the head of the world’s most prominent AI lab, has sounded the alarm. “Are we in a phase where investors as a whole are overexcited about AI? My opinion is yes,” Altman said in an August interview with The Verge.
It’s no secret that many experts have that feeling right now about the current AI boom. Even OpenAI CEO Sam Altman, the head of the world’s most prominent AI lab, has sounded the alarm. “Are we in a phase where investors as a whole are overexcited about AI? My opinion is yes,” Altman said in an August interview with The Verge.Should you make investment decisions based on those kinds of feelings and opinions?
Should you make investment decisions based on those kinds of feelings and opinions?I don’t know. I’m just a guy who writes personal finance articles. I don’t have any groundbreaking insights that conclusively prove that we are or aren’t in an AI bubble.
I don’t know. I’m just a guy who writes personal finance articles. I don’t have any groundbreaking insights that conclusively prove that we are or aren’t in an AI bubble.But I did ask financial economists at more than a dozen universities across the United States about it, and their responses were striking: More than 75% of economists we spoke to think the current AI investment boom is, in fact, a bubble.
But I did ask financial economists at more than a dozen universities across the United States about it, and their responses were striking: More than 75% of economists we spoke to think the current AI investment boom is, in fact, a bubble. More than 75% of economists we spoke to think the current AI investment boom is, in fact, a bubble.
Most of these economists, who hold positions at prominent universities, gave their answers on condition of anonymity, given the sensitive nature of the topic, but they cited a variety of evidence for their positions. Below, we’re breaking down the arguments for and against the theory that we’re in an AI bubble — and discussing how you can protect yourself if that theory turns out to be true.
Most of these economists, who hold positions at prominent universities, gave their answers on condition of anonymity, given the sensitive nature of the topic, but they cited a variety of evidence for their positions. Below, we’re breaking down the arguments for and against the theory that we’re in an AI bubble — and discussing how you can protect yourself if that theory turns out to be true.Brokerage firms
Brokerage firms
Brokerage firmson Charles Schwab's website
on E*TRADE's website
on Vanguard's website
on Fidelity's website
The case against the bubble theory
The case against the bubble theoryI’ll start by looking at the “not a bubble” and “maybe a bubble” responses. These were far fewer in number than the “yes” responses from economists, but they brought up an important point: There is real money in AI, and several of the biggest tech stocks are proving that with their earnings and revenue.
I’ll start by looking at the “not a bubble” and “maybe a bubble” responses. These were far fewer in number than the “yes” responses from economists, but they brought up an important point: There is is real money in AI, and several of the biggest tech stocks are proving that with their earnings and revenue.In its most recent quarterly earnings report, Nvidia (NVDA) reported a record $57 billion in revenue and $1.30 in earnings per share, giving it a price-to-earnings ratio (PE ratio) in the mid-40s range. Microsoft (MSFT) reported $77.7 billion in revenue and $3.72 in earnings per share in its most recent quarterly report, giving it a PE ratio in the mid-30s. Alphabet (GOOG) reported $102.3 billion in quarterly revenue and earnings per share of $2.87, giving it a PE ratio in the low 30s.
In its most recent quarterly earnings report, Nvidia (NVDA) reported a record $57 billion in revenue and $1.30 in earnings per share, giving it a price-to-earnings ratio (PE ratio) in the mid-40s range. Microsoft (MSFT) reported $77.7 billion in revenue and $3.72 in earnings per share in its most recent quarterly report, giving it a PE ratio in the mid-30s. Alphabet (GOOG) reported $102.3 billion in quarterly revenue and earnings per share of $2.87, giving it a PE ratio in the low 30s.These PE ratios are a little high — a “normal” PE ratio is typically somewhere in the 20s — but they’re not outrageous. All three stocks have actually seen decreases in PE ratio in recent years. Plus, there are plenty of non-AI stocks in much worse shape in terms of PE ratio. For example, CVS Health Corp. (CVS) has a PE ratio over 200.
These PE ratios are a little high — a “normal” PE ratio is typically somewhere in the 20s — but they’re not outrageous. All three stocks have actually seen decreases in PE ratio in recent years. Plus, there are plenty of non-AI stocks in much worse shape in terms of PE ratio. For example, CVS Health Corp. (CVS) has a PE ratio over 200.» See our list of the most undervalued stocks in the S&P 500
» » See our list of the most undervalued stocks in the S&P 500There are questions about many of the other big AI stocks. Tesla (TSLA) has a PE ratio over 300, and Palantir Technologies (PLTR) has a PE ratio over 400, for example. And there are also questions about whether Microsoft, Nvidia, Alphabet et al would still be able to rake in tens of billions of dollars in AI revenue in the event of a broad downturn in AI investment.
There are are questions about many of the other big AI stocks. Tesla (TSLA) has a PE ratio over 300, and Palantir Technologies (PLTR) has a PE ratio over 400, for example. And there are also questions about whether Microsoft, Nvidia, Alphabet et al would still be able to rake in tens of billions of dollars in AI revenue in the event of a broad downturn in AI investment.But for the time being, it’s actually kind of hard to make an argument that the multi-trillion-dollar AI behemoths like Nvidia, Microsoft and Alphabet are severely overvalued. They have the earnings to back up their stock prices, to some extent.
But for the time being, it’s actually kind of hard to make an argument that the multi-trillion-dollar AI behemoths like Nvidia, Microsoft and Alphabet are severely overvalued. They have the earnings to back up their stock prices, to some extent.The case for the bubble theory
The case for the bubble theoryThat said, 10 out of 13 economists surveyed by NerdWallet did ultimately say that we’re in a bubble. Here are some of the arguments they made for that position:
That said, 10 out of 13 economists surveyed by NerdWallet did ultimately say that we’re in a bubble. Here are some of the arguments they made for that position:Valuations are on the high end. The PE ratios of the biggest tech stocks, like Alphabet, Microsoft and Nvidia, might not be obscene, but they’re a little higher than what most would consider a typical PE ratio, and many other AI stocks have triple-digit PE ratios.
Valuations Valuations are are are on the high end. on the high end. The PE ratios of the biggest tech stocks, like Alphabet, Microsoft and Nvidia, might not be obscene, but they’re a little higher than what most would consider a typical PE ratio, and many other AI stocks have triple-digit PE ratios.Venture capital investment in AI startups is growing at a wild rate. It’s worth remembering that the stock market is not the only type of equity investment. Many economists noted that venture capitalists are throwing ever-growing amounts of seed money into just about any startup that claims to incorporate AI into its business model, and expressed doubts that that investment growth rate is sustainable or that it’ll produce real returns. Venture capital investments in AI companies surged 62% last year, according to Crunchbase.
Venture capital investment in AI startups is growing at a wild rate. Venture capital investment in AI startups is growing at a wild rate. It’s worth remembering that the stock market is not the only type of equity investment. Many economists noted that venture capitalists are throwing ever-growing amounts of seed money into just about any startup that claims to incorporate AI into its business model, and expressed doubts that that investment growth rate is sustainable or that it’ll produce real returns. Venture capital investments in AI companies surged 62% last year, according to Crunchbase.There are worries about “circular financing” between big AI companies. In recent years, a number of Big Tech firms have signed AI investment and hardware purchasing deals worth tens of billions of dollars… with each other. This raises the question of whether all of the AI revenue reported by the likes of Microsoft, Nvidia and Alphabet is organic, or whether much of it consists of money from other tech companies that have recently gotten flush with investment due to AI hype themselves.
There are worries about “circular financing” between big AI companies. There are worries about “circular financing” between big AI companies. In recent years, a number of Big Tech firms have signed AI investment and hardware purchasing deals worth tens of billions of dollars… with with each other each other . This raises the question of whether all of the AI revenue reported by the likes of Microsoft, Nvidia and Alphabet is organic, or whether much of it consists of money from other tech companies that have recently gotten flush with investment due to AI hype themselves.AI may have real value, but that doesn’t rule out a dot-com bubble scenario. Many of the “yes” responses did not doubt that AI as a technology has huge potential, but they cautioned that this doesn’t disprove the theory that we’re in a bubble — and that this line of anti-bubble argument is suspicious in and of itself. Some drew comparisons to the dot-com bubble of the 1990s and early 2000s: Back then, investors correctly recognized the transformative economic potential of the nascent internet, but they still got carried away with their investments in internet stocks, eventually leading to a big correction.
AI may have real value, but that doesn’t rule out a dot-com bubble scenario. AI may have real value, but that doesn’t rule out a dot-com bubble scenario. Many of the “yes” responses did not doubt that AI as a technology has huge potential, but they cautioned that this doesn’t disprove the theory that we’re in a bubble — and that this line of anti-bubble argument is suspicious in and of itself. Some drew comparisons to the dot-com bubble of the 1990s and early 2000s: Back then, investors correctly recognized the transformative economic potential of the nascent internet, but they still got carried away with their investments in internet stocks, eventually leading to a big correction.What you can do about it
What you can do about itIf you’re a longtime reader of The Nerdy Investor, or of NerdWallet in general, you probably have an idea of what we’re going to say here. When we write about a potential downside risk in the market, we often come back to the refrain that investment diversification is the best defense, and that index funds and ETFs are the easiest way for most investors to ensure they’re well-diversified.
If you’re a longtime reader of The Nerdy Investor, or of NerdWallet in general, you probably have an idea of what we’re going to say here. When we write about a potential downside risk in the market, we often come back to the refrain that investment diversification is the best defense, and that index funds and ETFs are the easiest way for most investors to ensure they’re well-diversified.Yeah, you could try to actively bet against potentially-overvalued AI companies by buying put options on them, short-selling them, or buying inverse ETFs that contain them, but these are risky moves that lose most people money.
Yeah, you could try to actively bet against against potentially-overvalued AI companies by buying put options on them, short-selling them, or buying inverse ETFs that contain them, but these are risky moves that lose most people money.Here’s the thing, though… If we are in an AI bubble, this may be one situation where many popular index funds aren’t that safe, either.
Here’s the thing, though… If we are in an AI bubble, this may be one situation where many popular index funds aren’t that safe, either many popular index funds aren’t that safe, either .Back in August, I wrote about how Nvidia made up about 8% of the entire S&P 500 index (around 7% today) by market capitalization, and how the seven largest S&P 500 stocks, which are all tech companies with substantial AI interests, make up about a third of the index. The situation is even more dire for the Nasdaq 100, where Nvidia makes up more than 13% of the index, and the top 7 stocks (all AI-related tech names) make up well over half of it.
Back in August, I wrote about how Nvidia made up about 8% of the entire S&P 500 index (around 7% today) by market capitalization, and how the seven largest S&P 500 stocks, which are all tech companies with substantial AI interests, make up about a third of the index. The situation is even more dire for the Nasdaq 100, where Nvidia makes up more than 13% of the index, and the top 7 stocks (all AI-related tech names) make up well over half of it.However, there are still ways to diversify through other types of index funds, if you think outside the box a little bit. Here are a few ideas:
However, there are still ways to diversify through other types of index funds, if you think outside the box a little bit. Here are a few ideas:The Dow Jones Industrial Average is one index that is tracked by several ETFs and mutual funds, and it isn’t disproportionately made up of Nvidia and other tech stocks, because it’s a stock price-weighted index rather than a market cap-weighted index. Nvidia makes up less than 2.5% of the Dow, and Big Tech in general accounts for less than 25% of it. (Check out our article on Dow Jones ETFs for more information).
The Dow Jones Industrial Average The Dow Jones Industrial Average is one index that is tracked by several ETFs and mutual funds, and it isn’t disproportionately made up of Nvidia and other tech stocks, because it’s a stock price-weighted index rather than a market cap-weighted index. Nvidia makes up less than 2.5% of the Dow, and Big Tech in general accounts for less than 25% of it. (Check out our article on Dow Jones ETFs for more information).The Russell 2000, an index of small-cap stocks tracked by many ETFs and mutual funds, is even less tech-y than the Dow. Tech accounts for less than 14% of it; it mostly consists of companies in the industrial, health care and financial sectors. One caveat: Small-cap stocks can be volatile. Although the Russell 2000 has limited exposure to AI and tech, it may still swoon in an AI bubble-burst scenario if investors are spooked into selling risky stocks in general. (NerdWallet maintains a list of the best-performing small-cap ETFs).
The Russell 2000 The Russell 2000 , an index of small-cap stocks tracked by many ETFs and mutual funds, is even less tech-y than the Dow. Tech accounts for less than 14% of it; it mostly consists of companies in the industrial, health care and financial sectors. One caveat: Small-cap stocks can be volatile. Although the Russell 2000 has limited exposure to AI and tech, it may still swoon in an AI bubble-burst scenario if investors are spooked into selling risky stocks in general. (NerdWallet maintains a list of the best-performing small-cap ETFs ).Equal-weight S&P 500 ETFs are one way to get exposure to the S&P 500 companies while solving the Nvidia/Big Tech concentration problem. As we wrote in this newsletter issue a few weeks ago, they’re less AI-exposed than regular market cap-weight S&P 500 funds, and often pay higher dividend yields, but they tend to have significantly higher fees as well, and have trailed normal S&P 500 ETFs in returns this year.
Equal-weight S&P 500 ETFs Equal-weight S&P 500 ETFs are one way to get exposure to the S&P 500 companies while solving the Nvidia/Big Tech concentration problem. As we wrote in this newsletter issue a few weeks ago, they’re less AI-exposed than regular market cap-weight S&P 500 funds, and often pay higher dividend yields, but they tend to have significantly higher fees as well, and have trailed normal S&P 500 ETFs in returns this year.International ETFs could also be worth a look. The Vanguard FTSE All-World Ex-US ETF (VEU), for example, is less than 14% tech stocks by market cap. (See our page on international ETFs to learn more).
International ETFs International ETFs could also be worth a look. The Vanguard FTSE All-World Ex-US ETF (VEU), for example, is less than 14% tech stocks by market cap. (See our page on international ETFs to learn more).» MORE: Best brokers for ETFs
» MORE: » MORE: Best brokers for ETFs About the author Sam Taube Sam Taube Sam Taube writes about investing for NerdWallet. He has covered investing and financial news since earning his economics degree in 2016. See full bio.Helpful resources
Helpful resources The Best-Performing Stocks in 2026 (By One-Year Returns) Stock Research: How to Analyze Stocks in 5 Steps (With Video Examples) Top 21 Most Undervalued Stocks in the S&P 500: June 2026 9 Highest-Yielding Monthly Dividend Stocks for June More like this Investment Basics Investing Stocks Best Robo-Advisors: Top Picks for 2026 We spent hours testing robo-advisors to find ones that charge low fees but still offer high-quality features, including automated portfolio rebalancing, exposure to a range of asset classes and financial planning tools. 2 By Alana Benson, Sabrina Parys Investing in Dividend Stocks: Guide, Calculator and Top 7 Yields for June 2026 Dividend stocks can be a great choice for investors looking for passive income and portfolio stability. Here's what to look for when evaluating dividend stocks and how to invest in them. 2 By Chris Davis, Sam Taube Best Brokers for Beginner Investors: Top Picks for 2026 We spent hours analyzing the best brokers for beginners to find ones that offer low costs, helpful educational content and a broad investment selection. Our testers also looked for trading platforms that are easy to navigate. 2 By Alana Benson, Bella Avila Best Investments: Where to Invest in 2026 Wondering where to invest your money this year? High-yield savings accounts, CDs, bonds, funds and stocks are all considered among the best investments available. Learn more about the risks, potential returns and how to get started. 2 By Chris Davis, Alieza Durana Best Brokerage Accounts for Online Investing and Stock Trading in 2026 Based on hours of analysis and hands-on testing, here are our picks for the best brokerage accounts based on their low fees, strong platforms, quality customer support and other factors. Chris Davis Best Robo-Advisors: Top Picks for 2026 We spent hours testing robo-advisors to find ones that charge low fees but still offer high-quality features, including automated portfolio rebalancing, exposure to a range of asset classes and financial planning tools. 2 By Alana Benson, Sabrina Parys Investing in Dividend Stocks: Guide, Calculator and Top 7 Yields for June 2026 Dividend stocks can be a great choice for investors looking for passive income and portfolio stability. Here's what to look for when evaluating dividend stocks and how to invest in them. 2 By Chris Davis, Sam Taube Best Brokers for Beginner Investors: Top Picks for 2026 We spent hours analyzing the best brokers for beginners to find ones that offer low costs, helpful educational content and a broad investment selection. Our testers also looked for trading platforms that are easy to navigate. 2 By Alana Benson, Bella Avila Best Investments: Where to Invest in 2026 Wondering where to invest your money this year? High-yield savings accounts, CDs, bonds, funds and stocks are all considered among the best investments available. Learn more about the risks, potential returns and how to get started. 2 By Chris Davis, Alieza Durana Best Brokerage Accounts for Online Investing and Stock Trading in 2026 Based on hours of analysis and hands-on testing, here are our picks for the best brokerage accounts based on their low fees, strong platforms, quality customer support and other factors. Chris Davis Best Robo-Advisors: Top Picks for 2026 We spent hours testing robo-advisors to find ones that charge low fees but still offer high-quality features, including automated portfolio rebalancing, exposure to a range of asset classes and financial planning tools. 2 By Alana Benson, Sabrina Parys Investing in Dividend Stocks: Guide, Calculator and Top 7 Yields for June 2026 Dividend stocks can be a great choice for investors looking for passive income and portfolio stability. Here's what to look for when evaluating dividend stocks and how to invest in them. 2 By Chris Davis, Sam Taube Best Brokers for Beginner Investors: Top Picks for 2026 We spent hours analyzing the best brokers for beginners to find ones that offer low costs, helpful educational content and a broad investment selection. Our testers also looked for trading platforms that are easy to navigate. 2 By Alana Benson, Bella Avila Best Investments: Where to Invest in 2026 Wondering where to invest your money this year? High-yield savings accounts, CDs, bonds, funds and stocks are all considered among the best investments available. Learn more about the risks, potential returns and how to get started. 2 By Chris Davis, Alieza Durana